When Can You Trust the Experts?: How to Tell Good Science from Bad in Education

When Can You Trust the Experts How to Tell Good Science from Bad in Education Clear easy principles to spot what s nonsense and what s reliable Each year teachers administrators and parents face a barrage of new education software games workbooks and professional develop

Interview Questions About When You Can Start Work However, if you do have another job while you re in the application process for a new one, you need to be tactful in how you answer This type of question can be a mechanism to test your ethics, so avoid the temptation to say tomorrow if you re currently employed. When Can You Retire Good Financial Cents You can use an online retirement calculator at sites like dinkytown and choosetosave to find out how much you should be putting aside to accomplish your retirement goals However, remember that a retirement calculator is a tool that can t estimate every factor of your unique circumstances. How to Answer This Interview Question When Can You Start If you signed an employment contract when you started your current job, hopefully you retained a copy that you can check Or, research to discover any local government regulations or union rules that may apply to you and your job. Benefits By Year Of Birth Social Security Administration You can retire at any time between age and full retirement age However, if you start benefits early, your benefits are reduced a fraction of a percent for each month before your full retirement age. Multiple Bankruptcy Filings When Can You File Again If you ve filed for bankruptcy in the past, you might be wondering how soon you can file for bankruptcy again Read on to learn about the time limitations for wiping out debts after previously receiving a Chapter or Chapter bankruptcy discharge. Driving test eligibility for teens California After you pass your driving test, you will be issued a provisional driver license With your provisional driver license, you must be accompanied and supervised by a licensed parent, guardian or other licensed driver years of age or older, or by a licensed or certified driving instructor when you How Soon Can You Get Pregnant After Having a Baby How soon you ll get pregnant again depends if you ll be breastfeeding or not Breastfeeding and the hormones that go along with milk production can suppress ovulation from returning. The Best Foods for a Post Diarrhea Diet No one can live on the BRAT diet indefinitely Whether you are just getting over a bout of gastroenteritis or suffer from diarrhea predominant IBS IBS D , at some point you will need to expand your diet to ensure the proper intake of nutrients. Benefits Eligibility Virginia Employment Commission You will be disqualified if the deputy determines that you quit your job without good cause, or you were fired from your job for misconduct in connection with your work You and your employer have the right to appeal the deputy s determination if either of you disagrees with the results. Holly Pruning Find Out How To Trim A Holly Bush Trimming Holly Bushes How To Prune Holly Bushes If you don t know how to prune holly bushes correctly, you can do harm than good For hedge pruning of holly bushes, pruning the lower branches shorter than upper ones is not recommended Maintain an even shape instead.

  • Title: When Can You Trust the Experts?: How to Tell Good Science from Bad in Education
  • Author: Daniel T. Willingham
  • ISBN: 9781118130278
  • Page: 153
  • Format: Hardcover
  • Clear, easy principles to spot what s nonsense and what s reliable Each year, teachers, administrators, and parents face a barrage of new education software, games, workbooks, and professional development programs purporting to be based on the latest research While some of these products are rooted in solid science, the research behind many others is grossly exaggeratedClear, easy principles to spot what s nonsense and what s reliable Each year, teachers, administrators, and parents face a barrage of new education software, games, workbooks, and professional development programs purporting to be based on the latest research While some of these products are rooted in solid science, the research behind many others is grossly exaggerated This new book, written by a top thought leader, helps everyday teachers, administrators, and family members who don t have years of statistics courses under their belts separate the wheat from the chaff and determine which new educational approaches are scientifically supported and worth adopting.Author s first book, Why Don t Students Like School , catapulted him to superstar status in the field of education Willingham s work has been hailed as brilliant analysis by The Wall Street Journal and a triumph by The Washington PostAuthor blogs for The Washington Post and Brittanica, and writes a column for American EducatorIn this insightful book, thought leader and bestselling author Dan Willingham offers an easy, reliable way to discern which programs are scientifically supported and which are the equivalent of educational snake oil.

    One thought on “When Can You Trust the Experts?: How to Tell Good Science from Bad in Education”

    1. When we think "science" and "education," we think of those teachers who taught us how to set the Periodic Table, break beakers, and light fires. What we don't think of are white-coat types holding a magnifying glass to education research. Still, in this day of "research-based" this and "best-practices" that, shouldn't we at least question what that means? Daniel T. Willingham certainly thinks so, and he wrote WHEN CAN YOU TRUST THE EXPERTS? HOW TO TELL GOOD SCIENCE FROM BAD IN EDUCATION in an at [...]

    2. Willinghams eerdere boek 'Why Don't Students Like School? A Cognitive Scientist Answers Questions About How The Mind Works And What It Means For The Classroom' vond ik erg interessant en nuttig, dus dit boek van hem wilde ik zeker lezen. Willingham stelde niet teleur, ook dit boek is weer goed geschreven, interessant en nuttig, zowel voor docenten, ouders als thuisonderwijzers.

    3. This book is specifically aimed at educators (teachers and administrators, but parents, too) who might be considering "educational software, games, workbooks or other programs" which claim to be "based on the latest research." While some of these products may be based on actual research, many are not. But how can you tell? Willingham discusses the history of science and the role it plays in persuading us and appeals to our biases (especially the "confirmation bias" where we look for "evidence" t [...]

    4. Not as practical as I would have liked. The final three chapters are where Dr. Willingham tells how to evaluate programs and research. His steps are to strip it and flip it, trace it and analyze it before deciding if it's a good fit for you/your school. Strip it of any emotional appeals, analogies, "experts", claims, etc. to determine what is being claimed.Flip it to see the adverse outcomes (if reading scores improve in 30% of students, what about the other 70%?), your/your school's behavior.Tr [...]

    5. I love Daniel Willingham's work. He is a cognitive scientist who focuses on education issues. I use his text "Why Don't Students Like School" in one of my undergrad classes b/c it is an engaging way of presenting research on how we learn. His most recent book has the same great writing style but is a little slower. It is still very good though and offers practical suggestions for reviewing research and deciding what claims to believe. I wish that policy makers, parents, and educators would apply [...]

    6. 370.72 WIL我不太同意他的教育基本观点,但书中讲的现象很值得思考If a man will begin with certainties, he shall end in doubts;but if he will be content to begin with doubts he shall end in certainties.---Francis BaconConfirmation bias p46"The first principle is you must not fool yourself, and you are the easiest person to fool". --- Richard Feynman p102"Them most difficult subjects can be explained to the most slow-witted man if he has not formed any idea of them already; [...]

    7. Educators are constantly bombarded with shiny new bells, whistles, and golden bullets that promise to "fix" what teachers do in their classrooms, raise test scores, and bring our youth up to 21st century technological speed. The problem is that many of these changes are misguided and can even backfire. Daniel Willingham questions these changes and more importantly gives the reader advanced tools to question them too. Every educator and concerned parent ought to digest the contents of this book.S [...]

    8. I wanted to stop reading when he puts his argument about the "Reading Wars". However, I wanted to give the book the benefit of the doubt so I skipped to part 2. Some of the tips given made sense, some were ones that I already do without even thinking. So maybe this book would be more useful for people who are easily taken in by ads. But cynics and sceptics are already good at filtering the good from the bad.

    9. I would give this book 3.5 stars. I really enjoyed Willingham's writing style, and felt like I gained a better understanding of how the human mind operates. It was easy to read, and I could grasp his arguments without any difficulty. The number of real-life examples that were woven into the text are what made the reading pleasant and what made the facts he was conveying concrete. One example is when he writes in Part One about how Coke introduced a new recipe in 1985, which they called New Coke, [...]

    10. As someone who was very used to reading scientific claims before entering the educational field, in a way I was depressed that this book needed to be written in the first place. But WIllingham's statement is accurate in that many teachers swallow advertising whole-hog and begin to implement widespread changes to curricula and class procedures that have been disproven or are logically nonsensical. In that sense, Willingham's text is a well-needed guide to theoretical claims.The book consists of t [...]

    11. Their are many urban myths in our culture. We hear a half-digested nugget out there in the ether or from a friend or colleague and take it in with out really looking into whether such a factoid is true or not. This happens a lot in education. Education is far from an exact science like physics. There are so many different factors that go into it and so many confounding cause and effect relationships that it is hard to sift the wheat from the chaff. For educators it is important to have tools tha [...]

    12. Not bad. A decent introduction to scientific and statistical reasoning as applied to educational issues. Some great insights, though mostly the book is written for laymen never introduced to scientific and statistical reasoning. Highly recommended for those educators not familiar with these types of reasoning, only moderately recommended for those that are. It should be required reading for everyone involved in educational policy and administration. But overall the book is far short of Willingha [...]

    13. I thought this book gave explicit step-by-step instructions on how to evaluate claims of programs that are researched based by looking into the claims.The structure was really helpful, chapters were organized by beginning with the easiest way looking into research claims made by (asking the consultant who is making the presentation for the citations), and moving towards more work-intensive, but thorough, methods of validating the research. Some of the survey questions that were used as examples [...]

    14. I thought the first five chapters were good because it talked about the difficulty of doing science in the education field. The rest was kind of an Idiot's Guide to Real Science. I'd skip the chapters, and read two other things:1) a very short but good blog post:sciencebasedmedicine/i2) a great book:Priceless: The Myth of Fair Value (and How to Take Advantage of It) by William Poundstone. Much more entertaining (at least to me)

    15. voor elke docent en consulter een must read. Ik lees het boek vooral ook als Listbegeleider aan de start van een nieuw List-traject zodat ik scherp blijf voor de eigen kracht/kennis/vaardigheden van de professionals binnen de school, immers dat is het uitgangspunt van een veranderingstraject.

    16. A must for teachers and, especially, school/district leaders. I think even just reading the title and a synopsis could incite a revelation -- at least, a reminder -- that we shouldn't immediately buy into (and/or buy) every idea that sounds good or seems to come from a reliable source.

    17. Excellent info, definitely useful, definitely need to be working with nearly all cylinders going while reading.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *