You Deserve Nothing

You Deserve Nothing You Deserve Nothing is told in three voices that of Will a charismatic young teacher Gilad one of Will s students who has grown up behind compound walls in places like Dakar and Dubai and Marie the

  • Title: You Deserve Nothing
  • Author: Alexander Maksik
  • ISBN: 9781848545724
  • Page: 469
  • Format: Paperback
  • You Deserve Nothing is told in three voices that of Will, a charismatic young teacher Gilad, one of Will s students who has grown up behind compound walls in places like Dakar and Dubai and Marie, the beautiful, vulnerable senior with whom, unbeknowst to Gilad, Will is having an illicit affair.

    One thought on “You Deserve Nothing”

    1. UPDATE: November 29, 2011 Turns out this book really was based on the author's transgressions. The Will Silver character is Maksik himself. jezebel/5863188/how-a-teacWith this new development, I'm going to leave the book without a rating. Here is my original four-star review: Bleak but mighty impressive.Teacher worship. Is there anything more universal or more potentially devastating? At the International School of France, Will Silver is a beloved teacher with two especially worshipful students. [...]

    2. I read this novel with no background information and loved it. Intelligent, reflective, beautifully written, excellent characters. Came on over to to write my rave review and for the first time saw other reviews that reference the fact that this is based on a true story (view spoiler)[by an author who was himself dismissed from the same international school as his main character for the same reason (a relationship with a student) (hide spoiler)]. Spent a bit of time mulling the matter over befo [...]

    3. In existential philosophy, the words "You deserve nothing" are not reproachful. Rather, they define human responsibility and imperative, and the fundamental freedom to choose (versus the determinist ideology of fate). Essence comes after existence, not before. Human beings encounter themselves, surge up in this world, and have the burden of choice. We are not blobs of fate and destiny powered by an outside, ontological force. We are that force; there is no karmic essence--the world, as such, is [...]

    4. I was quite electrified by this book, both because of its own power and because it was the first book I read post-Goldfinch that didn't feel hollow and superficial and awful by comparison. This is a strong, passionate, tightly coiled book, fierce and cracking, with a slew of characters (mostly teenagers) who are just bristling with frustrated rage. The plot is for sure in the vein of Dead Poets Society: Our hero is a dashing young(ish) teacher who is by god going to change his students' lives. A [...]

    5. "Oh my god."That phrase.Say it one way, it's shock, subversion.Another, it's excitement, possibility.But if you're saying it over. And over. And over. Out loud. While reading alone. It becomes, was only ever, goddamn fucking exasperation.This book was a goddamn fucking exasperation.-----Alright. Disclaimer: I am a teacher. This book is about a teacher, a very specific kind, you know the one -- the dreamy male high school English teacher who changes your life and hates the system and wears blazer [...]

    6. Maksik’s debut novel is not a perfect thing, though he does a magnificent job catching the idiom and inflection of high school enrollees in the International School of France (ISF), an American school in a wealthy enclave of Paris. Three voices interweave: Marie, a student learning the power of her sexuality; Will, a thirty-three year-old teaching Sartre, Camus, Faulkner, and Shakespeare in a senior English seminar; Gilad, a student in Will’s class who, with Will, witnesses a man being push [...]

    7. Remember the Million Little Pieces scandal, when Frey's "memoir" turned out to be fictitious? Well this is the same thing in reverse: a "novel" which turns out to be a memoir. The appalling story of a teacher committing custodial rape on a 17 year old student.No apology, no atonement, au contraire, she seduced him, you see, she asked for it, she felt good about it, she still dreams of him, all the usual excuses! How did Sebold, his editor and a rape victim herself, let him get away with that shi [...]

    8. Had I known just how good this novel would be, I would have saved it for a perfect winter day, with snow falling outside and the fireplace roaring.

    9. On the shelf, You Deserve Nothing looks like one of those god-awful misery memoirs (usually about rape or domestic violence) ubiquitous with WHSmith bestseller lists and Richard and Judy’s tv book club. Nevertheless, I’d read the angry reviews from Maksik’s ex-students with intrigue and was seduced by Alice Sebold’s stamp of approval (not to mention Waterstone’s comparison of Donna Tartt!). The story alternates between three protagonists: 1) Will, the ‘inspirational’ English teache [...]

    10. Wow, wow, wow. I hated the teacher at the heart of this book, and it turns out the pathology of this man, Silver, may actually be the pathology of the author himself, judging by the extensive controversy around Maksik's past teaching history and dismissal, for having an affair with a student. (Others have posted the Jezebel article below.) But metacognitively, this book can serve as a study on the droll and maybe dangerous interpretations of existentialism by someone who clearly has some mental [...]

    11. For those out there who have condemned me for posting a review that wasn't about a book, this is about the book which may be based on a true story that victimized a child. If so, I do not wish to give this author money any more than I wanted to give OJ Simpson money for his book.Since I am now in the limelight I feel compelled to mention that I always research the allegations of an author behaving badly before condemning them to my never read shelf. This was no exception. Maksik has been accused [...]

    12. Where do I start with this magnificent debut book? That it was so mesmerizing that I read 200 pages at one clip, skipping dinner, not coming up for air? That it was so brilliantly done that even now, I am mulling over some key scenes? That it combines very real characters with themes such as existentialism and myth-making and how we learn and why we learn?Let’s start at the beginning. Will Silver is a charismatic and damaged English teacher who teaches at the International School of Paris, whe [...]

    13. The characters seem almost cliched - the intellectual and loved teacher, the enlightened and different boy, the giddy infatuated girl - but I was relieved that the plot was more interesting. The main three characters each narrate portions of the book. The story revolves around the teacher, a character whom everyone else loves and admires but is somewhat of a mystery. Yet while the reader is granted insight into his mind through his own narration of the events, he doesn't reveal anything about hi [...]

    14. I don't think I can give my usual summary of this novel. I tried, and it just sounds so trite and dull. (In fact, this review was really hard to write, I've been trying for over a week and it's a mess, I apologise.) I will offer what I can and go from there, for context if nothing else. This is basically the story of a teacher and a student who have an affair - if we were to break the book down to its base plot - but I didn't know anything else, going on, and I'm not always sure I should give mo [...]

    15. I saw this reviewed by my daughter and decided to read it. I was totally engrossed for half the novel until I switched from thinking about it as literature to thinking about it as an educator. At first I was mesmerized by the main character Silver, a teacher of high school students who challenges his Seniors in an English seminar to read critically and think for themselves. The Paris setting lends itself well to the intellectual fabric of the book. On one level, I found it a fascinating read abo [...]

    16. Sometimes, I can be out of step with what the reading public likes and dislikes. This is one of those times. The Daily Mail says this is hugely satisfying and thought-provoking: Annie Sebold says it is one of the most engaged reads I've in years. It has a 3.59 rating on . I didn't feel these any of these things about this novel. Set in the International School of Paris, it is a story about a subject we are becoming well aware of these days: a teacher, Will, having sex with a student, Marie. But [...]

    17. I confess, I read this book only because my curiosity was peaked by the article about it on Jezebel, and I wanted to be able to judge it for myself.That said, it's sickening.The tone somehow manages to strike a balance between self-loathing and unparalleled conceit, which is a pretty staggering achievement in its own perverse way. I am, of course, reading this work through the lens provided me, that the characters involved and goodly number of the events portrayed are real. What Maksik has done [...]

    18. You Deserve Nothing is set in a private international high school in Paris (the setting being yet another character in the story), with compelling first-person narrations by two students and their revered English teacher who challenges them to think about their reading in moral and philosophical terms. They try to translate his intellectual messages to their lives and suffer the universal response of teenagers to the disappointments of adulthood as their beloved teacher seems to throw away his l [...]

    19. I really liked this book. While it was a fast read that wasn't particularly complicated, it reintroduced several ideas about life and our choices that we often tend to ignore or forget. It's not even that I had a strong connection any of the characters, but I found I could understand their sense of confusion and what led them to their choices. I read this book in one sitting, and walked away from it feeling like I had something to think about, rather than a lot of the mindless books I've been re [...]

    20. I had heard that the author might have used real events from his own life in this novel, so approached it with caution. Not to worry: Will (main character and should-know-better male half of a teacher/student relationship) doesn't come off smelling like a rose. Although it is a bit suspicious how much Marie is the sexual aggressor, and how Will (the author?) just seems to fall into becoming her lover because he doesn't care enough about life to "just say no" to her advances. Will is worshipped l [...]

    21. This is a really difficult book for me to review. Had I read it in a vacuum, I would have given it four stars. Of course, I didn't read it in a vacuum. I can't get the Jezebel article out of my head, and for that reason, I have to give this book one star.

    22. This promised much at the start but turned out to be a bit of a disappointment. I didn't much like the main character and the story just wasn't what I'd thought it would beGave it 3 stars but should have been 2 really

    23. I was fairly delighted, about a hundred pages into You Deserve Nothing, to see the squiggles from the cover image near the top of the page, presented as an excerpt from the notebook of one of the book's narrators. Gilad Fisher has just moved to Paris, and is a senior at the International School of France, where one of his classes is a seminar with Will Silver, a charismatic literature teacher. The squiggle has these words under it: "What is." And then there's this, from Gilad's notebook:Then ben [...]

    24. I received my advance copy of Alexander Maksik's debut novel from a publisher rep (I'm a bookseller). The rep briefly explained that the teacher (more or less the protagonist) is similar to Robin Williams' character from the film "Dead Poets Society", and that he starts an inappropriate relationship with a student, and that it gets interesting from there. Though this review refers to a pre-publication galley, I sincerely hope they publish the novel as is. It is enthralling (even if you find your [...]

    25. I'm so torn about how to review this book.This is one of those books that called out to me from the bookshelf; during every visit to my local used or chain bookstore, I'd see this on the shelf and feel connected to it somehow. I finally gave in and picked it up this month. I just read it in two days. Devoured it, more like. I loved the style, the story, the questions about morals and behaviour and authenticity. As a teacher and as a lover of Paris, I found the plot especially compelling. I was r [...]

    26. The setting is Paris, at an international high school, where we meet William Silver, a charismatic, inspiring young English teacher. Mr Silver’s classes are popular, the students find him interesting and inspiring, he challenges them to think for themselves, to question, to lead the class, to engage in discussion with him and with each other. He gets them thinking about big issues, life and death, religion, fate, through the medium of the literature they are studying. As we join the story, a s [...]

    27. I had many high expectations for this novel. It is set in Paris, a city I love. It was given to me by a reading friend who has similar tastes. It was edited by Alice Sebold. Most of all, I had read that the author was inspired by Albert Camus's The Stranger, a book and an author I rather revere. However, as the title proclaims, I deserve nothing.Reading the book was pure pleasure, almost guilty pleasure. What could be more enjoyable than a love story between an older man and a very young woman, [...]

    28. I had no idea about the controversy that surrounds this author who appears to have written a novel which is actually more memoir. I still would have read it, it still would have appealed to me if only to form my own opinion on it.Marie, what do I think of Marie? Well certain parts of her remind me a great deal of myself when I was 17, so immediately I feel for her. And Mr Silver, gosh what I would have done for a teacher like that anywhere through my academic career, probably more than Marie giv [...]

    29. There's a part of me that feels awful to give just two stars to a writer as skilled as Maksik, but for all my admiration for his skills at dialogue and characters and putting you in the hothouse environment of an international school in Paris, I could not get past the resounding moral void at the center of the novel.And so I guess I need to issue a SPOILER ALERT on this one to do my feelings justice.Will Silver is a teacher at a high school that attracts the children of the wealthy and the diplo [...]

    30. Solidly 4.5 and rounded up. Reflections on the past through three different perspectives - two students and a literature teacher at an international high school in Paris. I gather that it's about five years after the fact. I'm amazed that I was kept up until about 3am the three nights I spent reading it considering that it nearly always reiterates the plot points through at least two of these three different characters. Obviously there is immense power in perspective, especially when characters [...]

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *